Tài liệu Giá trị của cắt lớp vi tính trong chẩn đoán thiếu máu ruột ở bệnh nhân tắc ruột non

Nội dung text: Tài liệu Giá trị của cắt lớp vi tính trong chẩn đoán thiếu máu ruột ở bệnh nhân tắc ruột non

1. 7Ҥ3&+ậ1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8<+Ӑ& *,ẩ75ӎ&Ӫ$&Ҳ7/Ӟ39,7ậ1+7521*&+Ҭ1Ĉ2ẩ1 7+,ӂ80ẩ858Ӝ7Ӣ%ӊ1+1+ặ17Ҳ&58Ӝ7121 1JX\ӉQ'X\+QJ1JX\ӉQ+RD+XӋ1Yj9ѭѫQJ.LP1JkQ, 7Ú͵QJĈ̹LKͥF<+j1ͱL %͟QKYL͟Q+·XQJKͣ9L͟WĈ΁F %͟QKYL͟QĈDNKRD4XͩFW͗9LQPHF7LPHV&LW\ *LiWUͣFͿDF͇WOͳSYLWtQKWURQJFḰQÿRiQWKL͗XPiXUXͱWͷE͟QKQKkQW͇FUXͱWQRQ3Ḱ˿QJSKiSKͫLF΁X P{W̻WUrQE͟QKQKkQW͇FUXͱWQRQFKͽSF͇WOͳSYLWtQKYjSK̓XWKXͅWW̹L%͟QKYL͟Q+·XQJKͣ9L͟WĈ΁FW΃ WKiQJQăPÿ͗QWKiQJQăP7ͭQWḰ˿QJJͫPFiFG̽XKL͟XJͻLờWKL͗XPiXUXͱWWURQJW͇FUXͱW QRQÿ́ͻFP{W̻WUrQF͇WOͳSYLWtQKVDXÿyÿͩLFKL͗XYͳLN͗WTX̻SK̓XWKXͅWÿ͛ÿ́DUDÿͱQK̹\ÿͱÿ͏FKL͟X JLiWUͣFḰQÿRiQǴ˿QJWtQKkPWtQKYjWtQKFKtQK[iFFḰQÿRiQ.͗WTX̻QJX\rQQKkQGRWKRiWYͣYjGR Gk\FK͉QJOjQJX\rQQKkQFKͿ\͗XFyEL͗QFK΁QJWKL͗XPiXUXͱWFKL͗PO̿QÓͻWYjGͣFKWΉGR ͭEͽQJFyÿͱQK̹\FDRQK̽WFiFG̽XKL͟XWKjQKUXͱWQJ̽PWKXͩFNpPKR͏FNK{QJQJ̽PTXDLUXͱW KuQKELDNKtWURQJWKjQKUXͱWNKtWURQJNKRDQJSK~FP̹FFyÿͱÿ͏FKL͟XFDR.͗WOXͅQG̽XKL͟X WKjQKUXͱWQJ̽PWKXͩFNpPKR͏FNK{QJQJ̽PWKXͩFNKtWURQJWKjQKUXͱWNKtWURQJNKRDQJSK~FP̹FFyÿͱ ÿ͏FKL͟XYjJLiWUͣFDRWURQJFḰQÿRiQWKL͗XPiXUXͱWG̽XKL͟XTXDLUXͱWKuQKELDFyJLiWUͣFḰQÿRiQWKL͗X PiXUXͱWJLDLÿR̹QVͳP 7ӯNKyDWҳFUXӝWQRQKRҥLWӱUXӝWWKLӃXPiXUXӝWFҳWOӟSYLWtQK ,ĈҺ79Ҩ1Ĉӄ 7KLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJWҳFUXӝWQRQFKLӃP WҳFUXӝWQRQGDRÿӝQJWӯÿӃQÿӝ ÿһF NKRҧQJ  FiF WUѭӡQJ KӧS WҳF UXӝW QRQ KLӋXGDRÿӝQJWӯÿӃQ7UrQ&/97 GDR ÿӝQJ Wӯ    YӟL Wӹ OӋ Wӱ YRQJ Wӯ FyPӝWVӕGҩXKLӋXQKѭVӵJLҧPKRһFNK{QJ ÿӃQ19uYұ\YLӋFGӵÿRiQWuQKWUҥQJ QJҩP WKXӕF FӫD WKjQK UXӝW Gj\ WKjQK UXӝW WKLӃXPiXUXӝWWUѭӟFSKүXWKXұWFyờQJKƭDUҩW WөNKtWURQJWKjQKUXӝWSKQӅOӟSGѭӟLQLrP TXDQWUӑQJ7X\QKLrQFiFQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟF PҥFWDUJHWVLJQVXQJKX\ӃWPҥFKPiXWKkP ÿk\YӅNKҧQăQJGӵÿRiQWuQKWUҥQJQj\FӫD QKLӉPPӥPҥFWUHRVӕOѭӧQJGӏFKәEөQJWuQK FiFGҩXKLӋXOkPVjQJOjFKѭDÿӫFѫVӣFKөS WUҥQJWăQJWӹWUӑQJWKjQKUXӝWWUrQSKLPFKөS FҳWOӟSYLWtQK&/97FXQJFҩSFiFWK{QJWLQ WUѭӟFWLrPKRһFNKtWӵGRәEөQJ±7KHRWiF EәVXQJFyờQJKƭDFKRFiFEiFVƭSKүXWKXұW JLҧ0DXQJYjFӝQJVӵFKӍUDFyGҩXKLӋXJӧL WURQJ Gӵ ÿRiQ WKLӃX PiX UXӝW WURQJ WҳF UXӝW ờWuQKWUҥQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWGӏFKPҥFWUHRWҳF QRQ7URQJKҫXKӃWFiFQJKLrQFӭXÿӝQKҥ\ QJKӁQWƭQKPҥFKPҥFWUHRGӏFKWӵGRәEөQJ FӫD&/97WURQJGӵÿRiQWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJ JLҧPQJҩPWKXӕFWKjQKUXӝWYjGj\WKjQKUXӝW6 7KHRWiFJLҧ0DXQJYjFӝQJVӵÿmWLӃQKjQK 7iFJL̻OLrQK͟9́˿QJ.LP1JkQ QJKLrQFӭXWәQJKӧSYjFKӍUDGҩXKLӋXPӝW %͟QKYL͟QĈDNKRD4XͩFW͗9LQPHF7LPHV&LW\ OjWuQKWUҥQJJLҧPQJҩPWKXӕFWKjQKUXӝWFyờ (PDLO'UNLPQJDQUDG#JPDLOFRP QJKƭDWLrQOѭӧQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWKDLOjNK{QJ 1Jj\QKͅQ FyGӏFKWӵGRәEөQJFyWKӇORҥLWUӯWuQKWUҥQJ 1 1Jj\ÿ́ͻFFK̽SQKͅQ WҳFUXӝWQJKҽW Ӣ9LӋW1DPFyQKLӅXÿӅWjL  TCNCYH 138 (2) - 2021
2. 7Ҥ3&+ậ1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8<+Ӑ& QJKLrQFӭXYӅYDLWUzFӫD&/97WURQJEӋQKOt WҳFUXӝWQRQWX\QKLrQQJKLrQFӭXYӅYDLWUz FӫDFiFGҩXKLӋXGӵEiRWuQKWUҥQJWKLӃXPiX UXӝWWURQJWҳFUXӝWQRQWUrQ&/97KLӋQFzQKҥQ FKӃ9uYұ\FK~QJW{LWLӃQKjQKQJKLrQFӭXQj\ ÿӇFKӍUDJLiWUӏFӫDFiFGҩXKLӋXWUrQ&/97 WURQJGӵEiRWuQKWUҥQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJ WҳFUXӝWQRQ ,,ĈӔ,7ѬӦ1*9ơ3+ѬѪ1*3+ẩ3 ĈӕLWѭӧQJ 1KӳQJ EӋQK QKkQ ÿѭӧF FKҭQ ÿRiQ Oj WҳF UXӝWQRQFySKLPFKөS&/97Gm\әEөQJFy WLrPWKXӕFFҧQTXDQJYjFyELrQEҧQNӃWTXҧ VDXSKүXWKXұWWҥL%ӋQKYLӋQ+ӳXQJKӏ9LӋWĈӭF +uQK+uQKҧQKD[LDOSKLPFKөS&/97WKu WӯWKiQJQăPÿӃQWKiQJQăP WƭQKPҥFKGҩXKLӋXGj\WKjQKSKQӅOӟS 3KѭѫQJSKiS GѭӟL QLrP PҥF TXDL UXӝW QRQ NqP WKkP 1JKLrQF΁XKͫLF΁XP{W̻KͫLF΁X QKLӉP PҥF WUHR OkQ FұQ YQJ Kӕ FKұX WUiL .ӻWKXұW&/97ÿѭӧFWKӵFKLӋQWKӕQJQKҩW PNJLWrQӣEӋQKQKkQQDPWXәLWҳFUXӝW WKHR TX\ WUuQK FӫD NKRD FKҭQ ÿRiQ KuQK ҧQK GRGk\FKҵQJ %ӋQKYLӋQ+ӳXQJKӏ9LӋWĈӭF .ƭWKXұWÿѭӧFWLӃQKjQKWUrQPi\FҳWOӟSYL WtQKGm\2SWLPD*(+HDOWK&DUH6\VWHP 0LOZDNHH:LVWK{QJVӕTXpWN9P$ FҳWWӯWUrQYzPKRjQKÿӃQEӡGѭӟLNKӟSPX YӟLFiFOiWFҳWD[LDOÿӝGj\PPWiLWҥRWUrQFiF PһWSKҷQJD[LDOFRURQDOYjVDJLWWDOYӟLEӅGj\ PPWKXӕFFҧQTXDQJVӱGөQJORҥLLRGWDQ WURQJ QѭӟF LRELWULGRO ;HQHWL[  *XHUEHW OLӅXOѭӧQJPONJWӕFÿӝPOVVӱGөQJKӋ WKӕQJEѫPWLrPWӵÿӝQJ3KLPFKөSÿѭӧFWLӃQ KjQKӣWKuWUѭӟFWLrPWKuÿӝQJPҥFKV WKu WƭQK PҥFK FӱD V 7iL WҥR KuQK ҧQK WKHREuQKGLӋQFҳWQJDQJD[LDOÿӭQJQJDQJ FRURQDOYjÿӭQJGӑFVDJLWWDOFyGӵQJKuQK ÿiQKJLiPҥFKPiX +uQK+uQKҧQKFRURQDOSKLPFKөS&/97 WKuWƭQKPҥFKGҩXKLӋXNKtWURQJWKjQKUXӝW PNJLWrQӣEӋQKQKkQQDPWXәLKRҥLWӱ UXӝWQRQGRGRFKҵQJ TCNCYH 138 (2) - 2021 
3. 7Ҥ3&+ậ1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8<+Ӑ& 4X\WUuQKSḰ˿QJSKiSWKXWKͅSVͩOL͟X FKR KuQK ҧQK WURQJ VXӕW EuQK WKѭӡQJ FӫD 7 &iFEiFVƭFӫDQKyPQJKLrQFӭXÿӑFKӗL Pӥ .KtWURQJWKjQKUXӝWYӟLKuQKOѭӥLOLӅP FӭX WҩW Fҧ FiF SKLP FKөS FӫD EӋQK QKkQ KRһF FiF EӑW NKt WURQJ WKjQK UXӝW KRһF NKt WUrQ KӋ WKӕQJ SKҫQ PӅP ÿӑF SKLP ,QILQLWW WURQJWƭQKPҥFKFӱDNKLFyELӃQFKӭQJKRҥL  NӃWTXҧÿӑF ÿѭӧFJKLQKұQÿӝFOұSYӟLELrQ WӱUXӝW .KtWӵGRәEөQJNKtWӵGRWURQJ EҧQ NӃW TXҧ SKүX WKXұW &iF GҩX KLӋX Gӵ SK~FPҥF[XҩWKLӋQNKLFyELӃQFKӭQJWKӫQJ EiRWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJWҳFUXӝWQRQÿѭӧF UXӝWÿk\OjELӃQFKӭQJPXӝQ[XҩWKLӋQVDX 11 JKLQKұQ'j\WKjQKUXӝWWKjQKUXӝWGj\KӃW KRҥLWӱUXӝW 'ӏFKWӵGRәEөQJOjGӏFKWURQJ FKX YL WKjQK UXӝW ÿѭӧF FRL Oj Gj\ NKL Gj\ NKRDQJ SK~F PҥF GӏFK JLӳD FiF TXDL UXӝW 3 WUrQ PP ӣ TXDL UXӝW JLmQ7 4XDL UXӝW KuQK GӏFKJLӳDFiFQJiFKPҥFWUHR ELDOjKuQKҧQKOӟSGѭӟLQLrPFӫDTXDLUXӝW ;ӱOtVӕOLӋX JLmQ QJD\ WUrQ Yӏ WUt FKX\ӇQ WLӃS EҳW WKXӕF 6ӕOLӋXÿѭӧFQKұSEҵQJSKҫQPӅP(SLGDWD NpPKѫQVRYӟLOӟSQLrPPҥFYjWKDQKPҥF OjPVҥFKEҵQJSKҫQPӅP([FHOYj WҥR WKjQK WҥR UD KuQK ҧQK TXDL UXӝW JLӕQJ SKkQWtFKEҵQJSKҫQPӅP63666366 KuQKELDEҳQWKjQKUXӝWEӏWәQWKѭѫQJPҥFK ,QF&KLFDJR,/86$Yj([FHOYӟLFiF PiXVӁQJҩPWKXӕFFҧQTXDQJWKD\ÿәLWKHR WKXұWWRiQWtQKWUXQJEuQKWUXQJYӏYjÿӝOӋFK PӭFÿӝQJKLrPWUӑQJFӫDWәQWKѭѫQJPҥFK FKXҭQ FKRFiFELӃQ VӕÿӏQKOѭӧQJ YjWҫQVӕ PiX ĈӝQJҩPWKXӕFFҧQTXDQJVӁWKD\ÿәL WӹOӋSKҫQWUăPFKRFiFELӃQVӕÿӏQKWtQKĈӕL Wӯ WKjQK UXӝW Gj\ QJҩP WKXӕF EuQK WKѭӡQJ FKLӃX KuQK ҧQK &/97 YӟL NӃW TXҧ SKүX WKXұW ÿӃQKRjQWRjQNK{QJQJҩPWKXӕFFҧQTXDQJ ÿӇ WtQK Vӕ EӋQK QKkQ Fy NӃW TXҧ GѭѫQJ WtQK TXDLUXӝWKuQKELDQҵPJLӳDKDLWKiLFӵFQj\ WKұW GѭѫQJ WtQK JLҧ kP WtQK WKұW Yj kP WtQK FKӍ PӭF ÿӝ WKLӃX PiX QKѭQJ FKѭD WӟL JLDL JLҧ7ӯÿy[iFÿӏQK ÿӝQKҥ\6Hÿӝ ÿһFKLӋX ÿRҥQKRҥLWӱ7KjQKUXӝWQJҩPWKXӕFNpP 6SJLiWUӏGӵEiRGѭѫQJWtQK339JLiWUӏGӵ VR ViQK PӭF ÿӝ QJҩP WKXӕF FӫD TXDL UXӝW bỏo kPWtQK139YjÿӝFKtQK[iF$&&FӫD JLmQQJD\WUrQYӏWUtFKX\ӇQWLӃSYӟLFiFTXDL FKөS&/97WURQJGӵEiRELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiX UXӝWNKiFFQJPһWFҳWӣWKuWƭQKPҥFKWKjQK UXӝWWURQJWҳFUXӝWQRQ UXӝWEҳWWKXӕFNpPKѫQ70ҥFKPiXPҥFWUHR ĈҥRÿӭFQJKLrQFӭX EҳWWKXӕFNpPPҥFKPiXPҥFWUHREҳWWKXӕF 1JKLrQFӭXÿѭӧFWLӃQKjQKKӗLFӭXNK{QJ NpPKѫQVRYӟLPҥFKPiXPҥFWUHRFӫDFiF ҧQK KѭӣQJ ÿӃQ TX\ӅQ OӧL Yj VӭF NKӓH FӫD TXDLUXӝWNKiF73KYjWKkPQKLӉPPӥPҥF EӋQKQKkQ&iFWK{QJWLQYӅKӗVѫEӋQKỏnYj WUHRWăQJÿұP ÿӝPӥYjPӡPҥFWUHRWKD\ KuQKҧQKÿѭӧFFK~QJW{LEҧRPұW ,,,.ӂ748Ҧ 1JKLrQFӭXFӫDFK~QJW{LFyEӋQKQKkQÿҥWWLrXFKXҭQQJKLrQFӭX'ӵDYjNӃWTXҧVDXSKүX WKXұWWҳFUXӝWQRQFyEӋQKQKkQFyELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWYjEӋQKQKkQNK{QJFyGҩX KLӋXWKLӃXPiXUXӝW7URQJVӕEӋQKQKkQFyELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWKuEӋQKQKkQFKLӃP FyWLӅQVӱPәFNJQKyPQJX\rQQKkQGRWKRiWYӏYjGRGk\FKҵQJOjQJX\rQQKkQFKӫ\ӃX FyELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXWKjQKUXӝWFKLӃPOҫQOѭӧWYjEҧQJ7URQJEӋQKQKkQ FyELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWKuWKӡLJLDQWUXQJEuQKWӯO~FFKөS&/97WӟLWKӡLÿLӇPSKүXWKXұWOj ±JLӡ  TCNCYH 138 (2) - 2021
4. 7Ҥ3&+ậ1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8<+Ӑ& %ҧQJ%LӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJWҳFUXӝWQRQWKHRQKyPQJX\rQQKkQWUrQ&/97 6ӕOѭӧQJEӋQKQKkQ 7ӹOӋ Q  7KRiWYӏQJRҥL   7KRiWYӏQӝL   /ӗQJUXӝW 1  ;RҳQUXӝW 11  'tQK 3  'k\FKҵQJ 13  7UrQSKLPFKөS&/97GӏFKWӵGRәEөQJOjGҩXKLӋXFyÿӝQKҥ\FDRQKҩWJLiWUӏFKҭQ ÿRiQ kPWtQKFiFGҩXKLӋXWKjQKUXӝWQJҩPWKXӕFNpPKRһFNK{QJQJҩPTXDLUXӝWKuQKELD NKtWURQJWKjQKUXӝWYjNKtWURQJNKRDQJSK~FPҥFFyÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXFDROҫQOѭӧWOj Yj*LiWUӏFӫDFiFGҩXKLӋXGӵEiRWuQKWUҥQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWÿѭӧFWUuQKEj\ WҥLEҧQJ %ҧQJ*LiWUӏFӫDFiFGҩXKLӋXGӵEiRWuQKWUҥQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJWҳFUXӝWQRQWUrQ&/97 6ӕEӋQK 'ҩXKLӋX 6H 6S 339 139 $&& QKkQ 'ӏFKWӵGRәEөQJ 35      'j\WKjQKUXӝW 17      7KkPQKLӉPPӥPҥFWUHR 17      7KjQKUXӝWQJҩPWKXӕFNpP 22   76   NK{QJQJҩPWKXӕF 4XDLUXӝWKuQKELD       .KtWURQJSK~FPҥF 5      .KtWURQJWKjQKUXӝW 3      0ҥFKPҥFWUHRQJҩPWKXӕF 3      NpPNK{QJQJҩPWKXӕF ,9%ơ1/8Ұ1 %LӃQ FKӭQJ WKLӃX PiX UXӝW Oj ELӃQ FKӭQJ +XDQJ Yj FӝQJ Vӵ12  QJX\rQ QKkQ FKӫ \ӃX QһQJFҫQFDQWKLӋSFҩSFӭXÿӕLYӟLEӋQKQKkQ Jk\WҳFUXӝWQRQFyWKLӃXPiXUXӝWOj[RҳQUXӝW WҳFUXӝWQRQ7ҳFUXӝWQRQFyELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃX FKLӃP  Yj GR Gk\ FKҵQJ FKLӃP  PiXUXӝWWKѭӡQJJһSWURQJQKyPQJX\rQQKkQ FiFQJX\rQQKkQYLrPKD\EmWKӭFăQNK{QJ GR[RҳQUXӝWGRGk\FKҵQJYjGRWKRiWYӏ7KHR JһS ELӃQ FKӭQJ Qj\ 7URQJ QJKLrQ FӭX FӫD TCNCYH 138 (2) - 2021 
5. 7Ҥ3&+ậ1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8<+Ӑ& FK~QJW{LQJRjLQJX\rQQKkQFKtQKQj\QKyP ÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXJLiWUӏGѭѫQJWtQK QJX\rQQKkQGRWKRiWYӏEDRJӗPWKRiWYӏQJRҥL JLi WUӏ kP WtQK  ӣ QKyP WKLӃX PiX UXӝW YjWKRiWYӏQӝLFNJQJFyWӹOӋFDRFKLӃP WѭѫQJWӵYӟLNӃWTXҧSKkQWtFKWәQJKӧSFӫD Yj 7KHR +XDQJ12 QKӳQJ EӋQK QKkQ Fy WiFJLҧ0LOOHW1WUrQQJKLrQFӭXNKiFQKDXWKu WLӅQVӱSKүXWKXұWәEөQJWUѭӟFÿyFyWӹOӋWҳF GҩXKLӋXQj\FyÿӝQKҥ\WURQJFKҭQÿRiQ UXӝWELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWJҩSOҫQQKӳQJ WKLӃXPiXUXӝW'ҩXKLӋXWKkPQKLӉPPҥFWUHR EӋQKQKkQNK{QJWLӅQVӱQj\7URQJQJKLrQFӭX UXӝW Oj PӝW WURQJ QKӳQJ GҩX KLӋX JӧL ờ WuQK FӫDFK~QJW{LWӹOӋEӋQKQKkQFyWLӅQVӱSKүX WUҥQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWX\QKLrQNK{QJÿһFKLӋX WKXұWәEөQJFKLӃPWӹOӋFDR 7URQJQJKLrQFӭXFKRWKҩ\ÿӝQKҥ\Yjÿӝ ÿһF &/97 Fy WKӇ JL~S Gӵ EiR WҳF UXӝW QRQ Fy KLӋX FӫD GҩX KLӋX Qj\ WURQJ FKҭQ ÿRiQ WKLӃX ELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWÿӇFiFEiFVƭOkP PiX UXӝW OҫQ OѭӧW Oj  Yj  7URQJ VjQJFyFKLӃQOѭӧFWKHRG}LÿLӅXWUӏSKүXWKXұW QJKLrQ FӭX Fy  WUѭӡQJ KӧS Fy GҩX KLӋX FҩSFӭXFKREӋQKQKkQ3KkQWtFKFӫD0DOOR SKYjWKkPQKLӉPPҥFWUHRWUrQ&/97QKѭQJ YjFӝQJVӵ13WUrQQJKLrQFӭXÿӝFOұSÿmWuP NK{QJFyELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWÿѭӧFJLҧL UDÿӝQKҥ\FӫD&/97OjGDRÿӝQJWӯ WKtFKGRWURQJPӝWVӕQJX\rQQKkQQKѭYLrP Yjÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXGDRÿӝQJWӯ XFNJQJFyGҩXKLӋXWKkPQKLӉPPӥPҥFWUHR WURQJYLӋFFKӑQUDQKӳQJEӋQKQKkQEӏ 'ҩXKLӋXPҥFKPҥFWUHRQJҩPWKXӕFNpPKRһF WKLӃXPiXUXӝWQһQJ7KHRWiFJLҧ0LOOHWYjFӝQJ NK{QJQJҩPWKXӕFӣQKyPWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJ Vӵ1FiFGҩXKLӋXEҩWWKѭӡQJFӫDPҥFWUHRQKѭ QJKLrQFӭXFӫDFK~QJW{LFyÿӝQKҥ\Yjÿӝ ÿһF WKkP QKLӉP KRһF GӏFK Wӵ GR Fy ÿӝ QKҥ\ FDR KLӋX Oj  Yj  VR YӟL  Yj  ӣ WURQJNKLÿyFiFGҩXKLӋXEҩWWKѭӡQJFӫDWKjQK QJKLrQFӭXFӫD1DNDVKLPD77URQJQJKLrQFӭX UXӝWFyÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXFDR FӫD FK~QJ W{L QKұQ WKҩ\ UҵQJ GҩX KLӋX PҥFK PiXPҥFWUHRQJҩPWKXӕFNpPFKӫ\ӃXӣEӋQK 'ӏFKWӵGRәEөQJFyWKӇJһSWURQJFҧWҳF QKkQKRҥLWӱUXӝWĈk\OjGҩXKLӋXUҩWFyJLiWUӏ UXӝWFyELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWYjNK{QJFy WURQJYLӋFÿӏQKKѭӟQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝW ELӃQ FKӭQJ WKLӃX PiX UXӝW7X\ QKLrQ NKL Fy WKLӃXPiXUXӝWWKuGҩXKLӋXQj\JһSQKLӅXKѫQ 7KjQKUXӝWQJҩPWKXӕFNpPOjGҩXKLӋXWUӵF Yj Wӹ WUӑQJ GӏFK FNJQJ FDR KѫQ 7URQJ QJKLrQ WLӃSFӫDVX\JLҧPWѭӟLPiXUXӝWQRQYjÿѭӧF[HP FӭX FӫD FK~QJ W{L FKӍ ÿiQK JLi Vӵ [XҩW KLӋQ OjGҩXKLӋXÿһFKLӋXFӫDWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJFiF FӫDGӏFKWӵGRWURQJәEөQJYuYұ\ÿӝQKҥ\FDR QJKLrQFӭXFӫDQKLӅXWiFJLҧ7URQJQJKLrQFӭX QKѭQJÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXWKҩSWURQJGӵ GҩXKLӋXQj\ӣQKyPWKLӃXPiXUXӝWFyÿӝQKҥ\ ÿRiQWKLӃXPiXQһQJKD\KRҥLWӱUXӝW.ӃWTXҧ ÿӝ ÿһFKLӋX1JKLrQFӭXFӫDWiF FyVӵNKiFELӋWYӟLFiFQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟFÿk\ JLҧ1DNDVKLPD7YӟLÿӝQKҥ\Yjÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXOj EӣLVӵNKiFQKDXFӫDVӕOѭӧQJGӏFKOjPPӕF YjFyÿӝQKҥ\FDRKѫQQJKLrQFӭX FKҭQÿRiQ1ӃXFKӑQOѭӧQJGӏFKPӭFÿӝWUXQJ FӫD+D16Ojÿӝ ÿһFKLӋX3KkQWtFK EuQK WKu WKHR QJKLrQ FӭX FӫD -DQFHOHZLF] Yj WәQJKӧSFӫDWiFJLҧ0LOOHW1WUrQQJKLrQFӭX FӝQJVӵFiFJLiWUӏFӫDGҩXKLӋXQj\OҫQOѭӧW FNJQJFKӍUDGҩXKLӋXQj\Fyÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXFDRQKҩW OjYj1JKLrQFӭXFӫD%XUNLOOYj WURQJFKҭQÿRiQWKLӃXPiXUXӝWFKLӃPYj FӝQJ Vӵ15 YӅ GҩX KLӋX GӏFK ә EөQJ Vӕ OѭӧQJ WăQJNKҧQăQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJSKүXWKXұW QKLӅX WURQJ JӧL ờ WKLӃX PiX UXӝW FNJQJ Fy ÿӝ NKLFyGҩXKLӋXQj\OrQOҫQ1JKLrQFӭXFӫD QKҥ\OjYjÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXOj FK~QJ W{L Fy ÿӝ ÿһF KLӋX WѭѫQJ ÿӗQJ YӟL FiF QJKLrQFӭXWUrQQKѭQJÿӝQKҥ\FӫDFK~QJW{L 'ҩXKLӋXWKjQKUXӝWGj\FyÿӝQKҥ\  TCNCYH 138 (2) - 2021
6. 7Ҥ3&+ậ1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8<+Ӑ& WKҩSKѫQYuPүXQJKLrQFӭXFӫDFK~QJW{L[pW GҩX KLӋX Qj\ WURQJ QJKLrQ FӭX FӫD FK~QJ W{L WUrQWәQJWҩWFҧFiFEӋQKQKkQWҳFUXӝWFzQYӟL WKҩSQKѭQJÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXUҩWFDRĈLӅX ÿy FiFQJKLrQFӭXWUrQÿiQKJLiWUrQQKyPQJX\rQ FKRWKҩ\GҩXKLӋXTXDLUXӝWKuQKELDUҩWFyJLi QKkQFyQJX\FѫFDRWKLӃXPiXWKjQKUXӝWQKѭ WUӏWURQJFKҭQÿRiQWKLӃXPiXWKjQKUXӝWQKѭQJ WҳFUXӝWTXDLÿyQJWҳFUXӝWGR[RҳQ7KӵFWӃFiF FKѭDÿӃQJLDLÿRҥQKRҥLWӱ EӋQKQKkQFyKRҥLWӱUXӝWQKѭQJ&/97NK{QJ 'ҩXKLӋXNKtWӵGRWURQJSK~FPҥFOjELӇX WKҩ\GҩXKLӋXWKjQKUXӝWEҳWWKXӕFNpPWKӡLJLDQ KLӋQVӵWәQWKѭѫQJWKjQKUXӝWQһQJÿӏQKKѭӟQJ WӯO~FEӋQKQKkQÿѭӧFFKөS&/97WӟLO~FÿѭӧF ÿӃQELӃQFKӭQJWKӫQJUXӝW7URQJQJKLrQFӭX SKүXWKXұWNKiGjLWuQKWUҥQJTXDLUXӝWGLӉQWLӃQ FӫD FK~QJ W{L Fy  WUѭӡQJ KӧS Fy GҩX KLӋX WKLӃX PiX QһQJ KѫQ WURQJ WKӡL JLDQ FKӡ SKүX KuQK ҧQK NKt Wӵ GR ә EөQJ WѭѫQJ ӭQJ YӟL Fy WKXұWWURQJQJKLrQFӭXFӫDFK~QJW{LWKӡLJLDQ ELӃQ FKӭQJ WKӫQJ UXӝW ÿѭӧF FKҭQ ÿRiQ VDX WUXQJ EuQK Oj  JLӡ7URQJ QJKLrQ FӭX Fy  SKүXWKXұW&/97ÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXQKѭQJÿӝ EӋQKQKkQӣQKyPNK{QJWKLӃXPiXKRһFWKLӃX QKҥ\WKҩSWURQJFKҭQÿRiQGҩXKLӋXNKt PiXFyKӗLSKөFWURQJTXiWUuQKSKүXWKXұWFy WӵGRәEөQJWKҩSKѫQVRYӟLQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟF GҩXKLӋXWKjQKUXӝWEҳWWKXӕFNpPFiFWUѭӡQJ ÿy5 ĈLӅXQj\FyWKӇÿѭӧFJLҧLWKtFKEӣLNKRҧQJ KӧSQj\FyWKӇÿѭӧFJLҧLWKtFKGRQKXÿӝQJUXӝW WKӡLJLDQWӯO~FEӋQKQKkQNKӣLSKiWWҳFUXӝW ÿmOjPWKD\ÿәLYӏWUtFӫDTXDLNtQYjPҥFKPiX ÿӃQWKӡLÿLӇPWLӃQKjQKFKөS&/97WKӡLÿLӇP NKLӃQPҥFKPiXÿѭӧFOѭXWK{QJPӝWSKҫQYj WӯO~FFKөS&/97ÿӃQNKLSKүXWKXұWYjQKyP WiLFҩSPiXFKRTXDLUXӝW7X\QKLrQWKHRPӝW QJX\rQQKkQWҳFUXӝWӣPӛLFӥPүXFӫDWӯQJ Vӕ QJKLrQ FӭX GR WuQK WUҥQJ WҳF QJKӁQ PҥFK QJKLrQFӭXFyVӵNKiFELӋW PiXGүQÿӃQWLӃWGӏFKYjFyWKӇFKҧ\PiXWURQJ 6ӵ [XҩW KLӋQ FӫD NKt WURQJ WKjQK UXӝW FKR WKjQKUXӝWGүQÿӃQWăQJWӹWUӑQJFӫDWKjQKUXӝW WKҩ\KjQJUjRQLrPPҥFEӏSKiYӥQrQNKtWURQJ WUrQ&/97ӣQKӳQJEӋQKQKkQFyWKLӃXPiXUXӝW OzQJUXӝWNKtVӁYjRWURQJWƭQKPҥFKPҥFWUHR WURQJPә VDXÿyWKHRFiFWƭQKPҥFKFӱDYӅJDQ'ҩXKLӋX 4XDL UXӝW KuQK ELD [XҩW KLӋQ NKL OӟS GѭӟL Qj\ELӇXKLӋQWuQKWUҥQJKRҥLWӱQLrPPҥFKRһF QLrPEӏSKYjJLҧPÿұP ÿӝOӟSQLrPPҥFYj UiFKQLrPPҥFGRWәQWKѭѫQJUXӝW+uQKҧQKNKt WKDQKPҥFFzQEҳWWKXӕFEuQKWKѭӡQJ7KjQK WKjQKUXӝWQrQWiLWҥRWUrQPһWSKҷQJNKiFQKDX UXӝWWURQJQKӳQJWUѭӡQJKӧSQj\WKѭӡQJGj\ VӁÿiQJWLQFұ\KѫQGRKuQKҧQKEӑWNKtNҽWJLӳD Ĉk\OjGҩXKLӋXFyJLiWUӏFDRWURQJYLӋFÿӏQK KDLQӃSJҩSQLrPPҥFUXӝWWURQJTXDLUXӝWÿҫ\ KѭӟQJELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWNKLFKѭDFy GӏFKKuQKҧQKFKXӛLWUjQJKҥWNKLFҳWQJDQJTXD WuQKWUҥQJKRҥLWӱYuNKLTXDLUXӝWKRҥLWӱWKjQK EӑWNKtVӁWҥRKuQKҧQKOLӅPNKtJLӕQJNKtWURQJ UXӝW PӓQJ KѫQ Yj EҳW WKXӕF NpP KѫQ KRһF WKjQK UXӝW ӣ PӝW TXDL UXӝW Gj\ QӃX FҳW QJDQJ NK{QJ EҳW WKXӕF 7KHR %DOWKD]DU17 TXDL UXӝW TXDYDQUXӝW7URQJQJKLrQFӭXGҩXKLӋXNKt KuQKELDFyVӵWѭѫQJTXDQYӟLTXDLUXӝWWKLӃX WURQJWKjQKUXӝWFyÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXFDRWѭѫQJ PiXFyNKҧQăQJKӗLSKөFOҥLQKXÿӝQJYjPjX ÿӗQJYӟLFiFQJKLrQFӭXWUѭӟFÿy VҳFNKLÿѭӧFSKүXWKXұWJLҧLTX\ӃWQJX\rQQKkQ ӢQKyPWKLӃXPiXQһQJKRһFKRҥLWӱUXӝWWURQJ 9.ӂ7/8Ұ1 QJKLrQFӭXFӫDFK~QJW{LGҩXKLӋXQj\Fyÿӝ &KҭQÿRiQELӃQFKӭQJWKLӃXPiXUXӝWWURQJ QKҥ\Yjÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXOҫQOѭӧWOjYj WҳFUXӝWQRQFyờQJKƭDTXDQWUӑQJWURQJFKLӃQ 1JKLrQFӭXFӫDWiFJLҧ1DNDVKLPD7FyÿӝQKҥ\ OѭӧF WKHR G}L Yj SKүX WKXұW FiF WUѭӡQJ KӧS Yjÿӝ ÿһFKLӋXOjYjĈӝQKҥ\FӫD EӋQKQKkQWҳFUXӝW7URQJÿyWҳFUXӝWGRGk\ TCNCYH 138 (2) - 2021 121
7. 7Ҥ3&+ậ1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8<+Ӑ& FKҵQJGR[RҳQYjGRWKRiWYӏFyWӹOӋJһSELӃQ WKH 6XUJHU\ RI 7UDXPD SUDFWLFH PDQDJHPHQW FKӭQJQj\FDRKѫQ'ҩXKLӋXGӏFKWӵGRәEөQJ JXLGHOLQH - 7UDXPD $FXWH &DUH 6XUJ FyÿӝQKҥ\FDRFiFGҩXKLӋXFyÿӝ ÿһFKLӋX  FDROjNKtWURQJWKjQKUXӝWNKtWURQJSK~FPҥF  1DNDVKLPD . ,VKLPDUX + )XMLPRWR 7 PҥFKPҥFWUHRQJҩPWKXӕFNpPTXDLUXӝWKuQK HW DO 'LDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH RI &7 ¿QGLQJV ELDYjTXDLUXӝWQJҩPWKXӕFNpPKRһFNK{QJ IRU ERZHO LVFKHPLD DQG QHFURVLV LQ FORVHG QJҩP WKXӕF 7URQJ ÿy GҩX KLӋX JLҧP KRһF ORRSVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQ$EGRPLPDJLQJ NK{QJ QJҩP WKXӕF FӫD WKjQK UXӝW NKt WURQJ  WKjQKUXӝWYjNKtWӵGRәEөQJFyờQJKƭDFKҭQ 5KD6(+D+./HH6+HWDO&7DQG ÿRiQELӃQFKӭQJQj\GҩXKLӋXTXDLUXӝWKuQK 05,PDJLQJ)LQGLQJVRI%RZHO,VFKHPLDIURP ELD JӧL ờ WuQK WUҥQJ WKLӃX PiX UXӝW WUѭӟF JLDL 9DULRXV 3ULPDU\ &DXVHV 5DGLR*UDSKLFV ÿRҥQFKѭDKRҥLWӱ  7ơ,/,ӊ87+$0.+Ҧ2 )HF]NR3-0H]ZD'*)DUDK0&HWDO &OLQLFDOVLJQL¿FDQFHRISQHXPDWRVLVRIWKHERZHO 0LOOHW,7DRXUHO35X\HU$HWDO9DOXHRI ZDOO5DGLR*UDSKLFV &7¿QGLQJVWRSUHGLFWVXUJLFDOLVFKHPLDLQVPDOO ERZHO REVWUXFWLRQ $ V\VWHPDWLF UHYLHZ DQG  6HEDVWLj & 4XLURJD 6 (VSLQ ( HW PHWDDQDO\VLV (XU 5DGLRO  DO 3RUWRPHVHQWHULF YHLQ JDV SDWKRORJLF  PHFKDQLVPV &7 ¿QGLQJV DQG SURJQRVLV 5DGLRJUDSKLFV  =DOFPDQ 0 6\ 0 'RQFNLHU 9 HW DO +HOLFDO &7 VLJQV LQ WKH GLDJQRVLV RI LQWHVWLQDO  &KR .& %DNHU 65 ([WUDOXPLQDO DLU LVFKHPLDLQVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQ$-5$P- 'LDJQRVLV DQG VLJQL¿FDQFH 5DGLRO &OLQ 1RUWK 5RHQWJHQRO $P ,DFREHOOLV)%HUULWWR'%HO¿RUH03HWDO +XDQJ;)DQJ*/LQ-HWDO$3UHGLFWLRQ 0HDQLQJ RI IUHH LQWUDSHULWRQHDO ÀXLG LQ VPDOO 0RGHOIRU5HFRJQL]LQJ6WUDQJXODWHG6PDOO%RZHO ERZHO REVWUXFWLRQ SUHOLPLQDU\ UHVXOWV XVLQJ 2EVWUXFWLRQ *DVWURHQWHURO 5HV 3UDFW  KLJKIUHTXHQF\PLFURVRQRJUDSK\LQDUDWPRGHO GRLKWWSVGRLRUJ -8OWUDVRXQG0HG  0DOOR 5' 6DOHP / /DODQL 7 HW DO  *HIIUR\ < &ROHWWH ,% -XOOqV 0& HW DO &RPSXWHG WRPRJUDSK\ GLDJQRVLV RI LVFKHPLD ,QFUHDVHG XQHQKDQFHG ERZHOZDOO DWWHQXDWLRQ DQG FRPSOHWH REVWUXFWLRQ LQ VPDOO ERZHO DW PXOWLGHWHFWRU &7 LV KLJKO\ VSHFL¿F RI REVWUXFWLRQDV\VWHPDWLFUHYLHZ-*DVWURLQWHVW LVFKHPLDFRPSOLFDWLQJVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQ 6XUJ 5DGLRORJ\ -DQFHOHZLF]79X/76KDZR$(HWDO 6KHHG\63(DUQHVWWK))OHWFKHU-*HW 3UHGLFWLQJVWUDQJXODWHGVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQ DO&7RIVPDOOERZHOLVFKHPLDDVVRFLDWHGZLWK DQ ROG SUREOHP UHYLVLWHG - *DVWURLQWHVW 6XUJ REVWUXFWLRQLQHPHUJHQF\GHSDUWPHQWSDWLHQWV  GLDJQRVWLF SHUIRUPDQFH HYDOXDWLRQ 5DGLRORJ\  /L = =KDQJ / /LX ; HW DO 'LDJQRVWLF  XWLOLW\ RI &7 IRU VPDOO ERZHO REVWUXFWLRQ  0DXQJ $$ -RKQVRQ '& 3LSHU */ HW 6\VWHPDWLF UHYLHZ DQG PHWDDQDO\VLV 3OR6 DO (YDOXDWLRQ DQG PDQDJHPHQW RI VPDOO 2QH  GRLMRXUQDO ERZHO REVWUXFWLRQ DQ (DVWHUQ$VVRFLDWLRQ IRU SRQH 122 TCNCYH 138 (2) - 2021
8. 7Ҥ3&+ậ1*+,ầ1&Ӭ8<+Ӑ&  7DRXUHO 3* 'HQHXYLOOH 0 3UDGHO -$  %DOWKD]DU (- %LUQEDXP %$ 0HJLERZ HW DO $FXWH PHVHQWHULF LVFKHPLD GLDJQRVLV $- HW DO &ORVHGORRS DQG VWUDQJXODWLQJ ZLWK FRQWUDVWHQKDQFHG &7 5DGLRORJ\ LQWHVWLQDO REVWUXFWLRQ &7 VLJQV 5DGLRORJ\  GRL UDGLRORJ\ 6XPPDU\ 7+(9$/8(2)&20387('7202*5$3+,&,0$*,1*,1 ',$*126,1*,17(67,1$/,6&+(0,$$021*3$7,(176:,7+ 60$//%2:(/2%6758&7,21 3XUSRVH 7KLV VWXG\ DLPHG WR DVVHVV WKH YDOXH RI FRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSKLF &7 LPDJLQJ LQ GLDJQRVLQJLQWHVWLQDOLVFKHPLDDPRQJSDWLHQWVZLWKVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQ0DWHULDOVDQGPHWKRG 7KHUHFRUGVRISDWLHQWVZLWKVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQGHWHFWHGRQVOLFH&7LPDJLQJDWWKH9LHW 'XF8QLYHUVLW\+RVSLWDOIURP$XJXVWWR-XQHZHUHDQDO\]HGUHWURVSHFWLYHO\2QLPDJLQJ WKHVLJQVRILQWHVWLQDOLVFKHPLDZHUHGHVFULEHGDQGFRPSDUHGZLWKVXUJLFDOUHSRUWVDQGVHQVLWLYLW\ VSHFL¿FLW\SRVLWLYHDQGQHJDWLYHSUHGLFWLYHYDOXHVDQGDFFXUDF\RI&7LPDJLQJZHUHFDOFXODWHG 5HVXOWVKHUQLDVDQGEDQGVZHUHWKHPRVWFRPPRQFDXVHVRIERZHOLVFKHPLDDFFRXQWLQJIRU DQGRIWKHFDVHVUHVSHFWLYHO\)UHHSHULWRQHDOÀXLGKDGKLJKHVWVHQVLYLW\DW 5HGXFWLRQRUORVVRIERZHOZDOOHQKDQFHPHQWWDUJHWVLJQLQWUDOXPLQDOSQHXPDWRVLVLQWHVWLQDOLV DQGSQHXPRSHULWRQHXPDOOKDGKLJKVSHFL¿FLW\UDQJLQJEHWZHHWR&RQFOXVLRQUHGXFWLRQ RUORVVRIERZHOZDOOHQKDQFHPHQWLQWUDOXPLQDOSQHXPDWRVLVLQWHVWLQDOLVDQGSQHXPRSHULWRQHXP KDGKLJKVSHFL¿FLW\LQGLDJQRVLQJLQWHVWLQDOLVFKHPLDDQGWDUJHWVLJQFRXOGVXJJHVWHDUO\VWDJHRI LQWHVWLQDOLVFKHPLD .H\ZRUGVVPDOOERZHOREVWUXFWLRQLQWHVWLQDOLVFKHPLDLQWHVWLQDOQHFURVLVFRPSXWHG WRPRJUDSKLF&7LPDJLQJ TCNCYH 138 (2) - 2021